报告题目:社会科学研究中的“抄袭”(Plagiarism in the Social Sciences)
时间:2019年6月6日(周四)中午12:30-14:00
地点:管理学院大楼874教室 (金禾经济研究中心874教室)
报告人:Gary Hoover 教授
摘要:这次讲座将介绍若干有关社会科学研究中“抄袭”现象的重要调查的结果:Enders and Hoover(2004)在经济学期刊编辑中就“抄袭”定义及已知案例进行了调查,结果显示24%的编辑一年中通常会遇到一起抄袭的情况。而在另一份对1200名经济学研究人员进行的调查中,发现大量回答者对于“侵犯版权”和“抄袭”之间的区别并不清楚,且相当一部分的抄袭案例可以被认定为“层级式”的。此后 Stitzel et al. (2018) 又对更宽泛的社会科学期刊编辑进行了跟进调查,对业内的“抄袭”定义以及对疑似抄袭的处理办法进行了重新的了解。有趣的是,调查者发现不同学科间在“抄袭”的认定和惩罚上呈现出远高于学科内部的一致性。
This presentation reports the results of Enders and Hoover (2004) who surveyed economics journal editors about their definition of plagiarism and known cases. They found that nearly 24% of responding editors encountered one case of plagiarism in a typical year. In addition, this presentation reports the results of another survey of 1,200 professionals in the economics profession. That survey found that many of the respondents were not aware of the distinction between copyright infringement and plagiarism. In addition, that survey found that a substantial portion of the reported cases of plagiarism could be classified as ‘hierarchal’. In addition, this presentation reports the results of a follow-up survey of social science journal editors done by Stitzel et al. (2018). That work investigated what, if anything, has changed in regards to how journal editors react to suspected plagiarism and if the definition of plagiarism has changed. There is great variation within disciplines regarding the appropriate definition of plagiarism or punishments but fairly consistent agreement across disciplines.
讲座人介绍:Gary Hoover教授自2015年1月起任美国俄克拉荷马大学经济学系主任;Journal of Economics, Race and Policy 创刊编辑;2012年起任美国经济学协会(AEA)业内少数族群委员会联合主席;2018年秋起任(美)南方经济学协会(SEA) 副会长。
有意参加报告的师生请通过电子邮件报名,报名截止于6月6日9点。报名邮箱:zhifengxie@xjtu.edu.cn。
青年教师跨学科论坛以午餐会的形式每两周举办一次(根据需要可以加场),常设地点为文管大楼金禾中心874教室。论坛以人文社科青年教师为主,同时欢迎和邀请其他学科青年教师积极参加,针对跨学科问题进行报告和评论。
社会科学处
校青工委
青年教师跨学科论坛工作组
2019年6月5日